The average asking price for a used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia is $326,743, with 21,604 miles on average, across 23 cars for sale at U.S. dealers as of Nov 10, 2026.
Used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italias for sale at U.S. dealers ask $326,743 on average (half ask less than $331,190), across 23 cars. The cars for sale have 21,604 miles on average: one with fewer miles is worth more, and one with more is worth less. To check one car's price against cars of its trim and mileage, enter its VIN in OttoQuest's free Deal Check.
The 22 for sale with a listing date have been listed 66 days on average. A car listed much longer than that, or one whose price has already been cut, usually leaves more room to negotiate.
The 2011 asks $326,743 on average with 21,604 miles; the 2010 asks $383,037 with 20,588 miles, and the 2012 asks $358,479 with 20,928 miles.
NHTSA lists 4 safety recall campaigns that cover the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia. Repairs are free at a dealer of the make; check a car's VIN with NHTSA before you buy to see whether its recalls were fixed.
Used and certified cars for sale at US dealers, each car counted once. Days listed are the dealer’s own days on market where they publish it. Price moves compare the same cars at both ends of the window.
